Observer: Doomsayers of the Chinese economy will fall flat

People's Daily app
1795242086000

This year, certain overseas media outlets and institutions have repeatedly targeted China's economy. First, they hype up a so-called deflation trap, claiming that China's economic growth is unsustainable. Then, they stoke fears of a "China shock 2.0," claiming that Chinese manufacturing threatens global industries. Their talking points may change, but the pessimistic conclusions seem to have been written in advance.

Behind these narratives lie their own calculations of interest and political gain: they use the "China collapse" theory to shake confidence and the "China threat" theory to justify containment.

However, the development of China's economy is not up to these doomsayers.

Predicting China's collapse is nothing new.

In 2001, some in the West floated the "China collapse" theory, predicting that factors like its accession to the WTO would cause China to "collapse" by 2011. The prediction fell flat when 2011 came around.

In 2016, some external voices deemed a hard landing for China's economy "virtually inevitable." In 2023, The Wall Street Journal declared that "China's 40-year boom is over." This year, we are seeing a parade of claims about a "deflation trap," a “China shock 2.0" and "China economic crisis spillover."

For decades, the cacophony of voices predicting China's economic collapse has been relentless, only to be repeatedly refuted by reality.

This year's version generally falls into a few categories.

One is taking the part for the whole, extrapolating a temporary difficulty into an overarching crisis. In October, The Washington Post seized on short-term fluctuations in property prices and weak consumer confidence to one-sidedly declare China's economic prospects bleak. This narrative ignores the complexity of the economy as a whole, and its conclusions do not hold up to scrutiny.

Another is swapping concepts, framing competitive advantages in the market as threats to the world. When Chinese new-energy vehicles (NEVs) become a global hit, they hype up "overcapacity." When Chinese manufacturing becomes more competitive, they roll out the "China shock 2.0." Technological progress and efficiency gains are the very essence of market competition. Why does it become a risk to be guarded against when Chinese companies do it?

Then some start with the conclusion: no matter how China's economy develops, they will repeat the same negative rhetoric. If growth slows down, they say the growth model is unsustainable. If growth is maintained, they say it relies too heavily on policy stimulus. If exports face pressure, they question the competitiveness of Chinese manufacturing. If exports are strong, they attribute it to overcapacity and weak domestic demand. Either way, they always arrive at a negative conclusion.

In this way, economic analysis becomes a question with a predetermined answer. It is like making dumplings just as an excuse to use the dipping vinegar—the substance is entirely hollow, yet that does not stop them from making groundless accusations.

When you look closely, there is more behind why some people in the West are so obsessed with finding fault in China's economy.

In March, the Office of the US Trade Representative launched a "Section 301 investigation" into several economies, including China, citing alleged structural overcapacity in manufacturing. It explicitly stated its goal was to protect the US industrial base and promote manufacturing reshoring. Clearly, this is an attempt to preserve an existing advantageous distribution of interests.

In the past, companies from developed countries held the upper hand in high-end manufacturing. At the same time, China was mostly relegated to the low and mid-end of the international division of labor. Today, Chinese NEVs are driving into global markets, and breakthroughs in machinery and communications technology are constant. More and more Chinese companies are making a name for themselves in international markets.

The pie is still the same size, but the people sharing it have changed. Those who used to get the biggest slices are therefore feeling uneasy.

But does a competitive Chinese company necessarily mean "unfair competition"? Are popular Chinese exports necessarily a sign of "overcapacity"? If losing a competition means you can accuse the other side of breaking the rules, has market competition become a game where only one side is allowed to win?

Some politicians are also using China's name to further their own domestic political agendas. Blaming factory closures on the "China shock" and framing their own declining competitiveness as a "China threat" lets them divert attention from domestic issues and rally support for tariff barriers and trade restrictions. After all, it is much easier to blame China than to explain to voters their own policy failures and lagging industrial transformation.

Some people fundamentally harbor deep-rooted prejudices against China. They refuse to acknowledge the achievements of China's development path and insist on judging China by their own standards. They will stop at nothing to disparage China, attempting to undermine confidence in and the appeal of China's development, trapped in a pattern of habitual suspicion and condemnation.

With multiple factors intertwined, it is no surprise that these negative narratives persist.

Negative narratives cannot change the reality or trajectory of China's high-quality economic development.

In the first three quarters of this year, China's economy grew by 4.6 percent year-on-year, one of the fastest growth rates among major economies. In the first 10 months, foreign trade grew by 20 percent, with imports up 23.6 percent. The recently concluded ninth China International Import Expo also set new records, attracting participants from 162 countries, regions and international organizations, as well as 4,142 overseas exhibitors. While some claim China is losing its appeal, businesses around the world continue to show confidence in its market.

Of course, challenges remain. The property market is still adjusting, consumer confidence needs a boost and industrial upgrading takes time. China is responding by stimulating domestic demand, adapting property policies to local conditions and developing new quality productive forces by revitalizing traditional industries and nurturing emerging ones.

China's economy has weathered many challenges, from the COVID-19 pandemic to external pressure. Its resilience comes from steady policy direction, the hard work of its people and a sustained focus on its own development.

The recent 2026 APEC Economic Leaders' Meeting in Shenzhen offered another example of China's commitment to openness and cooperation. While some countries focus on building barriers and portraying others as threats, China is working with regional partners to build the four key pillars of an Asia-Pacific community: economy and trade, connectivity, innovation and development. Through concrete steps such as advancing regional trade agreements and fostering an open environment for innovation, China aims to promote shared development in the Asia-Pacific and contribute to building a community with a shared future for humanity.

As President Xi Jinping said, "No matter how the international landscape may evolve, China will not waver in its pursuit of win-win cooperation with all other countries."

The global economy is not a zero-sum game. Protectionism and trade barriers may serve narrow interests, but cooperation and openness create greater opportunities for all. The choice between the two approaches speaks for itself.

Ultimately, the facts speak louder than pessimistic predictions. China's future will be shaped not by those who doubt its prospects, but by the efforts of those working to build it.