OPINIONS US states must improvise rules to combat coronavirus in absence of federal help


US states must improvise rules to combat coronavirus in absence of federal help

By Li Zhiwei | People's Daily app

08:00, March 18, 2020


New York became one of the most affected area by coronavirus. (Photo: New York Times)

Washington (People’s Daily) – According to the New York Times, as of Tuesday, 5,303 cases of coronavirus have been identified in the US. 1,374 cases have been identified in New York state alone which has become the most affected area of the country. 

According to CNN, the number of Americans who have died from the novel coronavirus in the US has reached 100.

In the absence of federal aid, states and local authorities have to decide on rules. In Ohio and Massachusetts, restaurants and bars are closed, in Florida beaches have been closed and at least 32 states have closed schools.

The Guardian commented that emergency measures brought in across America to combat coronavirus differ from state to state – but for weeks they have had one thing in common: nobody was acting on guidelines issued by the federal government, because there weren’t any.

New York calls for help 

At a news conference Tuesday, New York Governor Andrew Cuomo announced that the virus had spread to at least 1,374 people in the state, hospitalizing 19 percent of them and killing at least 12.

Cuomo asked US President Donald Trump to help New York after their war of words. “It is essential that the federal government works with this state,” Cuomo said at the press conference in Albany. “We cannot do this on our own.”

The remarks offered a stark change in tone from just a day earlier, when the governor said the Trump administration has been “behind from day one of this crisis.”

Recently Cuomo fiercely criticized Trump’s leadership in the fight against the virus. “You see a whole hodgepodge of efforts being taken across the country,” said Cuomo, who announced a tri-state agreement on Monday with neighboring New Jersey and Connecticut to close all gyms, movie theaters and casinos.

“This state is doing this, this state is doing this, this city is doing this – it’s chaos. I think it actually feeds the feeling that the country’s out of control and there is no clear direction. This is a national problem, and we need federal leadership.”

Cuomo warned that intensive care units would soon be full and asked President Trump to send the Army Corps of Engineers to retrofit university dorms and other buildings to house those patients.

New York Mayor Bill De Blasio said he will limit all bars, restaurants and cafes to takeout or delivery services in New York City. De Blasio said the city's 8.4 million residents should prepare for a shelter in place order. The "very, very difficult decision" should be made in the next 48 hours.

"You have to think of this as something where you're going to see a massive mobilization to save lives, to help people through their suffering with this disease," the mayor said Monday.

Trump administration prepares to send money

US Public health officials said that the US has reached a tipping point, warning that if residents don't take the call to action seriously, the country may approach the situation in Italy, which went on total lockdown last week and where hospitals have been overwhelmed with more than 24,000 cases.

The federal administration on Tuesday launched a series of initiatives to further address the crisis. US Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin said that the Trump administration wants to send checks to Americans in the next two weeks in order to address the economic impact of the coronavirus outbreak.

The White House announced new guidelines recommending that people avoid gatherings of 10 or more and stay home if they’re sick. The recommendations said bars, restaurants and gyms should be closed “in states with evidence of community transmission” but no state was safe from community transmission.

But American media considers that the US federal government did not issue guidelines for the closure of businesses or restrictions on travel or large gatherings until Monday afternoon, leaving it up to America’s patchwork of state and local authorities to decide what rules are best.

Trump told state governors in a conference call on Monday that they should pursue the acquisition of key medical equipment themselves instead of waiting for Washington to act.

“Respirators, ventilators, all of the equipment – try getting it yourselves,” Trump told the governors, according to a recording obtained by the New York Times. “We will be backing you but try getting it yourselves. Point-of-sales, much better, much more direct if you can get it yourself.”

An NPR/PBS NewsHour/Marist poll released Tuesday shows that only 37 percent of those polled have either “a good amount” or “a great deal” of trust in the information they hear from the president about the coronavirus, while 60 percent say they do “not very much” or “not at all” trust Trump’s words on the subject.

States carry out sometimes contrasting orders

According to CNN, the number of Americans who have died from the novel coronavirus in the US has reached 100. “The grim milestone comes as health officials tout a consistent message: Limit your interactions now or overwhelm the health systems meant to take care of you. And get used to it, this won't be over soon.”


New York, Washington, California are the most affected areas by coronavirus. (Photo: New York Times)

In this situation, state governors have made rules on the fly. The Democratic governor of Illinois shut down all bars and restaurants in the state until next month. Pennsylvania announced similar restrictions, but only for certain counties. In Ohio, the Republican governor, Mike DeWine, announced statewide closures.

“We’re two days from St Patrick’s Day, when people get together and crowd into bars,” DeWine said. “We are at a crucial, crucial stage.”

The Maryland governor on Monday closed the port of Baltimore to cruise ships seeking to dock, banned evictions, mobilized state troopers, activated the state’s medical volunteer corps and announced the automatic reactivation of expired medical licenses.

Without federal guidance, local officials have in some cases issued conflicting orders. In Pennsylvania, the governor at the weekend advised people to stay home, and the commissioner of Montgomery county, which includes Philadelphia suburbs, told people to cancel gatherings.

North Carolina Gov. Roy Cooper said restaurants can only serve pickup orders or deliver food beginning at 5pm Tuesday.

Miami says that, by Wednesday, it will close all entertainment businesses, such as theaters, as well as fitness centers. Dine-in restaurants may sell food for takeout or delivery.


Related Stories

Terms of Service & Privacy Policy

We have updated our privacy policy to comply with the latest laws and regulations. The updated policy explains the mechanism of how we collect and treat your personal data. You can learn more about the rights you have by reading our terms of service. Please read them carefully. By clicking AGREE, you indicate that you have read and agreed to our privacy policies

Agree and continue