Court strikes down rule limiting F-1 and J-1 Duration of Status

China Daily
1794891494000

A federal judge in Massachusetts struck down a Department of Homeland Security regulation on Monday that would have eliminated the decades-old Duration of Status policy for international students and exchange visitors, handing a major legal victory to US colleges, academic unions and foreign scholars.

Photo via China Daily

This decision came as new data showed that international student enrollment in the United States declined by a large percentage in the 2026-27 academic year.

In a final judgment, US District Judge Dennis Saylor vacated the rule in its entirety. Judge Saylor ruled that the regulation violated the Administrative Procedure Act, finding the agency's overhaul to be "arbitrary, capricious and otherwise not in accordance with law".

The decision leaves intact the longstanding Duration of Status (D/S) framework, under which F-1 academic students and J-1 exchange visitors are admitted to the United States for however long it takes to complete their academic programs and authorized post-graduation training, provided they maintain full-time enrollment and comply with visa rules.

The DHS rule sought to dismantle the D/S system and replace it with fixed admission periods capped at four years for F-1 and J-1 visa holders, and 240 days for I-visa foreign media representatives.

In addition, international students would be prohibited from transferring to other schools, changing academic objectives, or pursuing a second degree at the same or lower educational level.

Despite receiving roughly 22,000 public comments warning of severe USCIS processing backlogs, disrupted research pipelines and diminished global competitiveness for American universities, DHS finalized the regulation with a scheduled effective date of Sept 15, 2026.

On Aug 18, a broad coalition including the Presidents' Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration, NAFSA: Association of International Educators, the American Federation of Teachers, the United Auto Workers, The NewsGuild-CWA and more, sued DHS in the US District Court for the District of Massachusetts.

Judge Saylor moved swiftly on the case, granting a nationwide preliminary injunction on Sept 14, just one day before the rule was to take effect.

Subsequently, the court denied the government's motion for summary judgment and rejected a fallback request from DHS to send the rule back to the agency for revision without formally vacating it.

In declining that request, the court noted that D/S had functioned smoothly for decades and that the contested rule had never gone into effect.

However, the federal government already has an appeal pending before the US Court of Appeals for the First Circuit stemming from the September preliminary injunction and is widely expected to seek appellate review of Judge Saylor's final judgment.

Meanwhile, higher education groups are bracing for another regulatory fight over a separate DHS proposal unveiled in October. The new proposal would impose a $70,000 fee on institutions recommending students for Optional Practical Training and an additional $30,000 fee for STEM OPT extensions.

Also on Monday, the Institute of International Education released results based on preliminary survey responses from 809 US higher education institutions, providing a preliminary snapshot for the 2026-27 academic year.

The data showed a broad downturn in international student enrollment. The total fall 2026 enrollment was down nine percent from last year, and new enrollment was down 15 percent.

The survey found that OPT participation began contracting this fall for the first time, dropping six percent due to visa processing friction and uncertainty over federal post-study work rules.

Notably, 95 percent of surveyed institutions warned that international students would likely look to other countries if US access to OPT is restricted.