WORLD How well are COVID-19 vaccines working in the real world?

WORLD

How well are COVID-19 vaccines working in the real world?

CGTN

07:07, March 02, 2021

Real-world studies into the effectiveness of COVID-19 vaccines have shown very positive results in reducing the risk of infection, as well as the risk of hospitalization and death if infected. (Photo: Agencies)

The development and approval of COVID-19 vaccines has happened at record-breaking speed and has prompted optimism that a pandemic, which has killed 2.5 million of the world's population, could be brought under control.

Millions of doses have been given to people since late 2020 – as well as the hundreds of thousands who took part in the trials before then. So far, the "real-world" picture suggests that vaccines are working well – even better than the figures were quoted in the trials.

It is still early days, with many uncertainties about the long-term protection from the vaccines, but here is a round-up of the latest statistics on the various vaccines published so far.

The statistics that matter

Israel has led the way in rapid vaccination, meaning it is among the first to present results from the real world rather than trials.

Its health ministry recently unveiled data showing the Prizer vaccine was 98.9 percent effective at preventing death by COVID-19 while decreasing the chance of hospitalization by the same percentage. It also reduced morbidity – that is, having the disease; morbidity is not to be confused with mortality – by 95.8 percent.

As World Health Organization chief scientist Soumya Swaminathan noted in February: "In all the clinical trials that have been done so far with the seven or eight [vaccine] candidates that we know about, there's been no case of a death or a severe disease with hospitalization occurring in the vaccine group."

There are different ways of judging how well vaccines are working – preventing infection, preventing illness, preventing serious illness and preventing death.

As it happens, across the board, those data on deaths and hospitalizations look really good.

Public health experts say it's important to look at all the statistics when measuring how effective a COVID-19 vaccine is, not just efficacy data from stopping infection. (Photo: Agencies)

Deaths

Up until now, most data on the efficacy of COVID-19 vaccines have come under controlled conditions in clinical trials, leaving an element of uncertainty over how results would translate into the real world with its unpredictable variables.

But promising real-world results have begun to emerge, as studies of vaccine effectiveness have taken place in both the UK and Israel – two of the countries leading the vaccination drives in their populations.

In Israel, a large study of the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine in 1.2 million people was published and peer-reviewed in the New England Journal of Medicine on Wednesday February 24.

The results of the landmark study for the Clalit Research Institute showed that the Pfizer vaccine was 84 percent effective in preventing death after 27 days of the first dose, increasing to 100 percent effective after the second dose.

Other real-world data in the UK published the same week by Public Health England (PHE) came from two studies of people also vaccinated with the U.S.-German Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine, which was the first to be used in the country in early December 2020.

The data analyzed the effect of vaccinations among the elderly in one study, while the other used a cohort of vaccinated and unvaccinated healthcare workers of various age groups.

Overall, England's public health agency said the data suggest vaccinated people who go on to become infected are far less likely to die. The data were backed up by the fact that the UK is currently recording falling death rates in all age groups – but the oldest age groups, who were the first to be vaccinated, are seeing the fastest decline since the peak in mid-January.

Data showed that in those aged over 80, the risk of dying was less than half (reduced by 56 percent) in vaccinated cases compared with unvaccinated cases, at least 14 days after receiving the first dose. PHE added that in the healthcare workers, overall, deaths from COVID-19 will be reduced by more than 75 percent according to the data.

But they explained the analysis only looked at those vaccinated at least 14 days earlier and it is likely that lower rates of death would be observed in those vaccinated more than three or four weeks earlier, and even more following the second dose – as occurred in the Israeli Health Ministry survey mentioned earlier, which recorded 98.9 percent lower death rates two weeks after the second jab.

Scientists explain it is not unusual for data on vaccine effectiveness in the real world to be lower than that released following clinical trials, particularly in the case of deaths among the older populations who are more at risk.

According to data from clinical trials, a high level of protection from the COVID-19 vaccines against death is also reported across the board for all the different vaccines. In fact, data from Moderna, Novavax, Oxford-AstraZeneca and Johnson & Johnson clinical trials show full or 100 percent protection from death due to COVID-19 in vaccinated people.

The same has been proved for China's CoronaVac vaccine, as Sinovac Biotech said late-stage trial data of its COVID-19 vaccine from Brazil and Turkey found the vaccine was 100 percent effective in preventing COVID-19 sufferers from dying.

In addition, late-stage trial data of Russia's Sputnik V vaccine published in The Lancet during February found the vaccine offered complete protection against death.

Hospitalizations

Real-world data have found that COVID-19 vaccines have contributed to a substantial drop in hospitalizations and provide a high level of protection from being hospitalized due to the effects of a coronavirus infection.

A recent study in Scotland conducted by the universities of Edinburgh and Strathclyde and Public Health Scotland was released on February 22, tracking the health of 1.1 million people vaccinated with either the Pfizer-BioNTech or Oxford-AstraZeneca vaccines.

The study found the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine reduced the hospitalization rate among inoculated Scots by 85 percent from four to six weeks after their first dose, while the Oxford-AstraZeneca vaccine reduced the chance of hospitalization by 94 percent after one dose. Overall combined data show an 84 percent reduction in hospitalization up to 34 days after one dose.

Among those aged 80 years and over – one of the highest risk groups – data showed the vaccination was associated with an 81 percent reduction in hospitalization risk in the fourth week when the results for both vaccines were combined.

In the Public Health England study of over-80s given the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine, data after 14 days of the first dose showed that those who develop COVID-19 infection after vaccination are around 40 percent less likely to be hospitalized than someone with infection who has not been vaccinated.

The Israeli study from the New England Journal of Medicine showed that effectiveness of the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine against hospitalization was 74 percent up to 27 days after the first dose and 87 percent after two doses. The separate Israeli Health Ministry data suggested a 99.2 percent rise in effectiveness two weeks after the second jab.

In the clinical trials of the other vaccines, including Moderna, Novavax and Johnson & Johnson, all the data showed very high to complete protection of the vaccines from hospitalization.

As for trials of China's CoronaVac vaccine, data showed it was 100 percent effective in preventing COVID-19 sufferers from being hospitalized, and 83.7 percent effective in avoiding cases that required any medical treatment.

Infection and symptomatic disease

Data analyzed in the various real-world studies mentioned above also show that vaccines do provide high levels of protection against infection and symptomatic disease, even from the first dose.

The UK's Public Health England (PHE) study of the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine in healthcare workers showed that one dose reduces the risk of catching infection by more than 70 percent, rising to 85 percent after the second dose.

In the PHE study of over-80s, data showed that one dose is 57 percent effective against a COVID-19 infection occurring from about three to four weeks after the first dose – adding that the second dose improves protection against by a further 30 percent, to 88 percent.

The Israeli New England Journal of Medicine study found that among 600,000 people who received two doses of the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine, 94 percent fewer people got a symptomatic COVID-19 infection compared with an unvaccinated group of the same size.

The study also showed that a single dose of the vaccine was 57 percent effective in protecting against symptomatic infections after two weeks, which rose to 92 percent after two doses.

As for data from the clinical trials, the 12,396-person study of China's CoronaVac vaccine found that it was 50.65 percent effective at keeping people from getting infected following two shots.

According to late stage trial results of Russia's Sputnik V vaccine published in The Lancet medical journal, it gave around 92 percent protection against a COVID-19 infection.

Related Stories

Terms of Service & Privacy Policy

We have updated our privacy policy to comply with the latest laws and regulations. The updated policy explains the mechanism of how we collect and treat your personal data. You can learn more about the rights you have by reading our terms of service. Please read them carefully. By clicking AGREE, you indicate that you have read and agreed to our privacy policies

Agree and continue